The Document the Witness Had Never Seen
More than once at a deposition, I’ve handed a witness a paper document and asked a simple question: “Can you identify this document?”
My deponent looks at it and says, “No. I’ve never seen this before.”
The document is the deponent’s, but maybe the deponent is hiding something. Or maybe the witness truly doesn’t remember or recognize it. Either way, the pages in front of the deponent have been cut loose from the day they were written. The document has no hour, no cabinet or folder it came from, and no sense of why it was written or for whom or where it traveled. The deponent isn’t looking at something from the working day it came from. The deponent is looking at an object presented alone on a stage of its own, as though it had appeared unannounced.
The Words and the Breadcrumbs
This week my class worked on collection, the step where information leaves the custodian’s world and begins to enter the case. The custodian is the person whose files are being collected, and who may later become our witness. We usually describe the goal in terms of content: get the files, keep them intact, and prove nothing changed.
Today the document I handed that witness is more likely an email or a file, and how we collect it changes what we can recover. There is an additional way of looking at collection. The words of a document, its body text, are why we collect it, and nothing replaces them. But an electronic file carries more than its words. It may carry the date it was created, the hour it was last changed, the device that produced it, the folder it sat in, and who authored and received it. Each is a breadcrumb, a small trace of a day the custodian lived with the words of the document. The words say what was written. The breadcrumbs begin to say where it came from, for whom, and why it mattered that day. Think of the document as part of a human totality, with connections that light up its meaning and the meaning of the world around it.
Open a photo on your phone and look at it. Then check the information icon. You’ll see when it was taken, with what, and where. The picture is the heart of it, but who doesn’t check a photo’s metadata when a memory won’t quite come back? The memory is not only the picture. It is the picture seen in the context of what happened, to whom, when, and why. ESI gives us little gifts, and little gifts can make all the difference.
Now take a screenshot of the same photo. The picture survives, but much of what made it meaningful is gone.
That is how digital breadcrumbs get lost, often by someone trying to help. A conscientious employee, told to gather “the relevant files,” drags them onto a thumb drive. The drive is copied, then emailed, and the dates and trail quietly change along the way. This is why we say custodians shouldn’t collect their own data. A custodian knows where the work lives and its context. But once a custodian handles the files, the files have changed, and so has what they disclose about the custodian and others. Careful collection protects the trail with tools like hash values, a digital fingerprint showing that the file that arrived is the file that left, preserving the breadcrumbs.
One Crumb Is Helpful, but It Is Not the Whole Neighborhood
A single timestamp means very little, and so does a single message. Each becomes richer when read alongside others: the calendar entry that morning, the chat message an hour earlier, the draft saved twice before the final, the people copied and the one who wasn’t. Together, they begin to form a path through someone’s week, a week of work on case issues, but also work with others. I don’t think I ever had a case with one player. We live inescapably in a world with others, where we do our work with others, against others, pushed by others, and thanked by others.
We have never been able to pull the multitude of breadcrumbs and text together easily. Search tools gave us fragments, hits without their surroundings, like the proverbial bag of words with few or no ways to see which ones lay side by side. Yes, search improved over the years, providing relationship wheels and other helpful reconstruction tools, but the reconstruction was still abstract. Hence, the traditional reliance on depositions. But the human in a deposition forgets, dodges, weaves, and sometimes even lies.
Today, AI has changed things. You can ask AI to gather the messages and their breadcrumbs around a single week or a single decision and show what was pressing on the people involved, who was waiting on whom, where two accounts disagree, and where the record goes quiet. And you can keep going, because it is a dialogue. It resembles taking a deposition of the data, with a witness who is tireless and cooperative, though one whose answers you still check against the documents.
The dialogue isn’t a way to have the machine tell us what our witness was thinking. It is a way to stretch our own imagination so that we come to understand the witness’s experience: the phone, the laptop, the inbox, and the chat threads the witness worked in, the pressures and struggles of the job, and what the witness hoped for and feared. Then we can ask better questions. In my article this past June, “The Recovery of Meaning in a Digital Age: E-Discovery and the Renewal of Judgment,” 30 J. Tech. L. & Pol’y (2026), I argue that AI can help recover the context that judgment depends on. AI can illuminate, but it cannot judge. It can measure and calculate. It can recall, suggest, and compare. But it can’t tell me whether to accept the settlement, whether to call a dangerous witness, or whether a request for social media is fair and proportional. And before any client material goes into such a tool, make sure it is one your firm has approved for confidential and privileged data.
The Map and the House
A company’s org chart, records policy, and list of systems are a kind of map: tidy, accurate as far as it goes, and drawn from a distance. A custodian’s working life is more like a house, with rooms where the main work happens, stairs between one task and the next, closets where things get put away, and hideaways where the things that matter most are kept. Nobody lives on a map.
Breadcrumbs are not a better map. They are traces left inside the house: the late-night draft, the message copied to a colleague, the folder only the custodian would think to name. Following them with AI brings us closer than any chart could, because they carry what mattered to the person at the time. Even so, we remain visitors. If I walk into the deposition convinced that I know what the witness thought, I have mistaken my tour for the life lived there.
Our work isn’t finished when the crumbs are gathered. It continues in a room with the witness, the only one who can show me around, including the closets and hideaways the breadcrumbs only hint at. The path I’ve pieced together gives me better questions. The message itself might say only “Fine, send it.” Read alone, that is nothing. Read with its breadcrumbs, it is a story, and I can ask our witness, “This was sent at 11:42 on a Thursday, from your phone, after three edits. Walk me through that night. Who were you on the phone with?” And so it goes, but not blindly.
And the witness may tell me: the deadline, a call from a manager, the reason for being up so late. At that point the page stops being an exhibit between us. It becomes a way back into something that happened. Words matter a lot. Breadcrumbs matter a lot. Even more important, together they matter most.
A friendly reminder
Protect the words and the crumbs: ask for natives, and don’t drag, screenshot, or forward ESI. Use the tools to put the pieces together and use the AI dialogue to widen your view of the witness’s situation. Then treat what you have built as a set of questions and take them to the person who lived it. Good questions don’t pull meaning out of a witness; they make room for it. You may be surprised how readily the witness’s world shows itself, and how much it means, when we let it.
